ING’s global economic outlook for 2027
2027 could be make or break for the global economy.
Will AI unleash a productivity boom, transforming growth and the jobs market? Or will the remarkable surge in US tech finally come crashing down, taking business investment with it? Can Europe’s surprising economic resilience continue, or will dramatic elections, political brinkmanship and rising bond yields herald a return to stagnation?
Join ING’s economists as we launch our 2027 Economic Outlook. We’ll take you through our biggest calls for the year ahead, and the unexpected twists that could knock the global economy off course.
You’ll learn:
Whether the US growth story can keep defying expectations, powered by booming AI investment and resilient consumer spending
How higher energy prices and political upheaval could reshape the outlook for Europe’s major economies
Where inflation is heading and whether we’ll see second-round effects from the mounting energy crisis
What we expect from the major central banks, including the Federal Reserve, European Central Bank and Bank of England
The biggest upside and downside risks for 2027
Details
Date: Tuesday 10 November
Time: 1400 GMT/1500 CET/0900 ET
The webinar will last 40 minutes, including a Q&A session at the end.
The event will take place online and the waiting room will open 60 minutes ahead of the scheduled start time.
A joining link will be emailed following registration and you will receive a reminder email 10 minutes before the scheduled start time.
View transcript
Welcome to our Macro outlook for 2027. where the theme is all about power. from shifting political power to battles over energy trade. and technology power in all its forms is set to shape the outlook. for the year ahead. Now, when we look at the starting points for next year, it's really one of... economic resilience, especially when you consider the energy crisis that we've experienced this year. But when you dig a bit deeper, things look a little bit more uneven. Growth is more concentrated and narrow in summer. economies. And of course, that energy crisis, while it's not over, it could throw up some surprises for growth. and inflation in the year ahead. We've just had the midterm elections in America. President Trump is now a lame duck. Could he also be an angry duck? And what about the elections in France and all of the budgetary problems? that we have over there. There's a lot to unpack today. and we'll be doing that with our experts who are here. So let me introduce them to you starting. with Carsten Brzeski, who's Global Head of Macro, looking at the Eurozone and the ECB. James Knightley is our International Economist, looking at US and the Fed. And here in the studio with James Smith Developed markets Economist, looking at the UK. okay and the bank of england i'm Rebecca Byrne if you've got a question there is questions tab We'll get to them at the end, but let's kick things off with a poll for you. Most Economist, expect growth in America of sort of one and a half, two and a half. percent next year. But which of these risks is greater, that growth exceeds 3%? or growth falls below 1% and even enters. a recession? Put your answers in. and we'll come back to them in just a bit. But let's go straight James Knightley. James, you're expecting welcome. You're expecting growth of around 2% to 2.5% next year. which sounds pretty healthy. But you've described that growth, as I was saying in the intro. as increasingly narrow. So where is this growth actually coming from? And does this narrowness actually make the economy more vulnerable? than might be suggested by that headline number. Yeah, thanks, Rebecca. So, yeah, I mean, two, two and a half percent, very respectable. Well that's what we're expecting it to really continue for the next couple of years. But as you say, I'm just a little bit nervous about the lack of breath. to that growth story. We always talk about US consumer and consumer spending is critical to the growth outlook. 70% of all economic activity. Is consumer spending here in the United States much more so than in Europe and in Asia? And here we talk about bifurcation a lot. or the case-shaped consumer whereby Middle and lower income households really feeling pressure from a jobs Markets not doing very much, wages that aren't really rising very much. but the cost of living does keep increasing. We saw that again with today's inflation prints as well. So that squeeze on spending power remains an issue. Whereas high-income households who have got vast or seen vast wealth gains, we've got to remember that the top 20% of households in America owns 70% of the wealth. So it's big stock market gains, the big property market. price increases really being concentrated there so As a result, we see sentiments. is strained, yet spending is holding up and that just causes me a little bit of nervousness there. We look at the tech sector and business investments and we know that business capex is has been roaring ahead, but it is overwhelmingly driven by tech and AI related spending. Outside of tech and AI, we've actually seen business capex contract. And at the same time, we're also looking at trade because of this big tech investment boom. So much of this is coming from abroad. imports have been surging. We can see that in this chart here that But yeah, the tech capex in AI and data centers really. very vibrant, that light pink section at the top, the actual data center construction, the small thin. move area. Also contributing, but look at imports, net imports, really big subtraction because we're spending so much. on this high value added, high cost item. So that's why I say the growth numbers look pretty good, but it is that concentration risk that So it makes me a little bit nervous. Well, we've got the results of the poll and they are quite interesting. Most Economist, expect 1.5%, 2.5% US growth next year. You think that the risks are tilted. more towards growth falling below 1% and even entering a recession. 59% of you. 41% saying that growth might exceed 3%. James Democrat is now in control of Congress. This clearly constrains Donald Trump's agenda. Does a president who is constrained at home become more unpredictable abroad? And what could that mean for tariffs and Iran and the rest of the world? Yeah. So with the Democrats gaining control of Congress, they've won the House, they've won the Senate. they control the legislative agenda. So it's very difficult for Republicans to try and get anything that they want. through. But likewise, the Democrats are going to have a challenge as well, because the president has his veto. And of course, we all saw him with his cap. Mr Vito and there is a sense that we are going to get this gridlock. Story and that raises all sorts of issues about potential government shutdowns down the line. as well. But what does the president do? It's difficult to imagine that he's just going to quietly slip into retirement over the next two years he's going to be wanting to be there and you know being presidential. But when you've got a lack of... power over what's happening in domestic policy, you've got to look at where you do have authority. And those are areas of... presidential powers, our executive authority, and those large foreign policy and trade policy. So think about tariffs, think about also So what he's going to do with Iran, what is the Russia-Ukraine story going to look like? by look like and also potentially i think this is a bit of an outside risk, China, Taiwan, whether he chooses to weigh in there. I think that's... much less likely. So yeah, he's still got lots of levers. that he can still pull. less than he had before, but he can still exert a lot of influence. over Global economy. We've just got to wait and see. That said, because of these election results, he is going to be be feeling more challenges. We can see that with the impeachment proceedings starting against Pete Hegseth yesterday. But also I think, you know, The Democrats are going to be pushing back much more in Congress, looking to get people to appeal. appear before committees to justify actions much more But also, look at the Republican Party themselves. I mean, they are starting to make... maneuvers towards 2028 jd vance marco rubio lots of rumors swirling around there that That very explicit social media commentary by JD Vance is to Why the debt, why the Republicans did so badly. perhaps we're going to see more pushback internally. Now within the Republican Party as well. So I think it's going to be very, very interesting. But, you know, the issue is. Donald Trump is very much his own man, very much his own beast, and there is always uncertainty about what he's going to do. what he can do. Indeed, indeed. But let's talk about the Fed. You are expecting one more Fed. rate hike in December and then a long pause. through 2027. But how confident are you that the Fed can just sit on the sidelines for that long, given... all of these economic and political risks that we've talked about. Yeah, and the risk to our view is again highlighted this morning by Chris Waller's comments London. suggesting that he's certainly going to back a 25 basis point hike at December. Could. possibly go for 50. If inflation doesn't cool in today's hotter... than anticipated inflation prints, sort of giving more juice to that trade that we've seen Markets. It's today. So certainly lots and lots of risks. Our view is predicated on the idea that we will see a Yeah. a disengagement in the Middle East that will help to get energy prices lower. And remember, gasoline prices have already fallen 50 cents. A gallon here in the United States, so with the lowest gasoline price since July. So that should really be helpful for inflation. We also got to remember that US inflation basket is very... The difference in the European inflation basket housing. has a weighting of about 35%. And interest rate sensitive sectors such as housing, already feeling cool winds coming through. So we are expecting the house price story, the rent story to also help. But remember too, what is the biggest cost input for corporate America? It's not tariff. It's not energy, it's not cost of microchips, it's the cost of you and I, it's the cost of workers and unfortunately for you and I. wage growth has really slowed. We've got wage growth of just 3%. And that low hire, low fire Economist, not going to be turning that story around anytime soon. So I think. Assuming these trends are in play, I'm pretty happy with the view that we get another rate hike in December. but don't necessarily need to see additional ray moves. But as we know, we could see a re-escalation in Iran. You know, the president could feel constrained. he could listen to the hawks we could see renewed action there so that's clearly a risk. But also AI, we just don't really have a great handle on what the productivity enhancements. about AI will mean, what it could mean for the jobs market, what it could mean for inflation pressures as well as a result of that. So, yeah, we're pretty happy with our base case view, but certainly we do acknowledge that there are risks both to the upside. and to the downsides from here. All right, thanks, James. We'll be coming back to some of those risks a little bit later on. But now we're going to go. So another poll. This time we want to know what the probability is that the ECB... has to restart bond purchases next year. So less than 10%, 10% to 25%, 25% to 50%. percent or more than 50 percent Put your answers in, and we'll come back to them in a second. But we're going to go to Carsten. So Carsten, you expect the Economist, grow by around 1% next year. You say it's resilience, but not strong. So tell us about that forecast. What's underpinning that resilience and why isn't? the economy expected to do even better. Yeah, Rebecca, it's again this typical European modeling through. Well, you know, resilient, but not really, not really taking off. I think what we're seeing underneath this headline number is... So it's a bit of rebalancing of growth across the region. So what is underpinning this growth number is clearly... German fiscal stimulus, a continuation of Germany growing. This year, we expect Germany to have grown by one, one and a half percent. would be the fastest growth since 2022. They should continue in 2027 on the back of ongoing fiscal stimulus. At the same time, we see that the fiscal and political problems in France are... Clearly weighing on French growth. An economy that until recently was actually one of the growth drivers of the European economy. And then also at the same time as the funds. from the European Recovery Fund. are expiring. They will no longer boost the southern European economies. So this is why we also expect those economies to slow down a little bit. So that's the rebalancing of. growth story um and then a bit you know the same external factors that James mentioned are clearly determining also our forecast. So above all, it is energy prices. It is long-term interest rates, which will probably also weigh on growth going forward. going forward so it is this mix of positive physical stimulus in a few countries. At the same time, the delayed or lacked more negative impact from this year's higher energy prices and surge in... and ultimate interest rates that is holding back the European economy from growing faster. Well, let's talk about those oil and gas prices, because obviously one big assumption behind that outlook is that they... These prices normalize over the course of 2027. But the energy situation is highly uncertain. There are also questions about whether these second round effects. from energy have just been delayed. rather than avoided. So what does all this mean for your inflation outlook? Yeah, well, obviously, all pressure is on our commodity expert, Warren Patterson, because we're... Basing like James US. we're basing a lot of our inflation forecasts on our base case scenario for energy. ...and then actually our base assumption on how the war in the Middle East will... will evolve well currently when you look Markets um you know it it becomes a rather benign scenario on on oil prices. But going forward, going into 2027, we clearly expect that. The oil prices are lower, that they are coming down, that they will remain at around to 75 dollars per barrel that is clearly a bit of tailwind, particularly for... for European industry, but also for consumers as similar to what is happening in US, gasoline prices will also then come down. somewhat that is positive you mentioned gas prices and you're and you're right gas prices will only reach the economy with a clear delay. We know this from the past. So normally the surge in gas prices that we saw over the last couple of weeks weeks will only reach consumers. at the start of 2027. So also pushing up inflation. in the first quarter of 2027, as this is the moment when most European consumers see their, well, their new energy contracts. So what does all of this mean for the ECB? It is indeed we're currently seeing a headline inflation that had. had gone up to 4% in the Eurozone. But when you look at core inflation, it's relatively well behaved, 2.5%. So this inflation shock that we're currently seeing has not really become a broadening inflationary shock. It is almost exclusively. in energy price shock. And in our base case scenario, so where we expect... energy prices to come down. First oil prices, then retail gas prices a bit later. So this is a situation in which we do not expect... many second round effects or not even London effects to the rest of the economy. And why is that? Because final consumption, so the consumer households. are not really financially in a situation in which they can. and want to pay higher prices. So this means that the higher import costs that firms clearly have cannot entirely, probably hardly at all. be passed through to consumers instead. What we're expecting is that somewhere in this production chain, we will see profit margin squeezing. So while in 2022, 23. There were many talks about greedflation or profit inflation. So companies actually are increasing price and then making more profits. We'll probably see a reversal this time around. And this reversal is... one in which firms will have to absorb the inflationary pressure, the cost pressure, so that it will not show up in. in headline inflation numbers So what's this mean for the ECB? You've got one more hike priced in for December. What happens after that? Yeah, indeed. Well, the ECB more or less telegraphed already the December hike. I think that is almost a no-brainer. Remember at the press conference, Christina Gard said that the ECB already We discussed a rate hike now at the October meeting. given that headline inflation will not really substantially come down by. by December I think the December rate hike is is almost up almost a done deal, we'll never know. Also because the financing costs and that is longer term interest rates. had gone up since the summer. So that is also weighing on economic activity in Europe. If we are right. with our base case and this base case of one clearly in headline inflation coming down on on the back of lower energy prices to no real significant London effect or second round effects so this current inflation shock remaining exclusively an energy price shock. then there is no reason for the ECB to continue hiking in 2027. If we are wrong, that's awesome. If we are wrong and energy prices were. to remain higher for longer. if we were to see more of the London effects, so inflation broadening. across the European economy, then indeed... we might see one or two additional more rate hikes by the ECB. but this is not our base case, it's a risk scenario. All right. Thank you, Carsten. Over James Smith, right here with me in the studio. James, talking about inflation, you're expecting inflation to rise in the UK this year. Now, one... A statistic that caught my eye reading your outlook. was that household utility bills are going to go up by 30% by April next year. So obviously I've been buying the candles in preparation for this. How much of an inflation problem does this... create and how worried are you that this energy shocks? will spread more broadly through the economy. Yeah, it's not good news because the UK is very reliant on natural gas prices. And we know that... The rise in natural gas prices we've seen over the last few months, even though it comes down a bit, that's pretty much baked in now for January. that household utility bills are going up 25% and yeah, maybe they keep going up in... In April, let's see what happens to gas prices through the winter. But that's locked in and that means inflation above 4% is also pretty much locked in now. We're forecasting... 4.3% in January. it's not really good news. Energy by that point will be contributing somewhere between one and a half. and two percentage points to overall inflation that four percent which also means that core inflation is a bit less of problem. We think it kind of rises about 3%. percent kind of this winter. But when you look at some of the nuts and bolts here, it's less worrisome. So food inflation particularly. Okay, that's not part of core inflation, but it's an important part for the Bank of England. so benign right now. It's very low and actually producer price inflation for food is negative. So the supermarkets are under a lot of... pressure to keep prices prices low a lot of competition Energy intensive goods and services is stuff that's not energy, but is very influenced. by energy prices, the inflation rates for those products. down this year, not up. And then there's the jobs Markets, this hasn't been a good story this year. The jobs... The Markets been under pressure, particularly consumer services. it's stabilizing if you look at some of the surveys, but we don't expect it to heat up next year. And that means wage growth is going to stay. pretty benign as well. So it's kind of the same story as what Carson was describing there for Europe. There's not a lot of pressure for those second round effects to come through. And remember, we've had a dress rehearsal for this in the UK already. Last year, inflation got to almost 4%. Yet there was no sign of second round effects. And by February this year, the Bank of England was kind of sounding the all. clear so i think this is the template for this time Okay, but if we're all spending more money on energy, that means we have less money to spend on other... stuff right so how much of squeeze does this really put on consumers And, you know, and what does it mean for growth next year? Yeah, so like everywhere, the consumer has been pretty resilient this year. We've seen this. Right the way across Europe, growth has been held up really well. I think that's partly because until very recently, those gas... prices hadn't started rising so as inflation really picks up to four percent this winter I think that's when it gets hard for consumers. So I think growth does slow into the winter. But then there's the AI story. You James has talked about this for US. And one thing we've learned this year, this is actually... quite important for the UK as well, data center investment. is picking up. The UK is kind of at the epicenter of that really in Europe. Nothing on a scale as US. But the UK kind of stands out over here on the continent for... for AI. And then there's professional services, which sounds a bit random, but this has been controversial. ...beating enormous amounts of growth this year, so kind of tech... and these professional services. This is stuff like solicitors, advertising. for whatever reason have been rocketing this year and those two sectors contributing well over half of the growth we've seen over the last few months. The question is, why is that? Is it AI and the productivity? I'm a little bit skeptical about that, maybe a little bit. so these are the kind of the key questions which let's see what happens through the winter but overall slower growth I think. Okay, now you're expecting a hike in February. but then you say the bank could actually be cutting rates by the end of the year. So what changes in the year to take the... going from hiking rates in February to potentially cutting by the end of the year. So a lot of this is still the reason the Bank of England hike rates in November. and probably will do again in February. A lot of this is still kind of the inflation risk. It's not what we're seeing in the data. It's ensuring themselves against, you know, if the war in Iran really does get a lot worse. So that's why I think they stay hawkish until then. But I think by the spring or into early summer... I think that's the point where we'll be more than a year on from the start of the crisis. If the second round effects were going to materialize. We would have started to see them by then. I think the April inflation report... report which comes out in May will be very important. That's when all these price rises at the start of the year come through. If we can get through all of that, it doesn't look too bad. Then I think the bank starts to sound all clear. And actually, UK interest rates are really bearing down on UK growth. at the moment. If we look at how much the average mortgage rate has changed since the low in 2021, It's like 200 basis points here in the UK because UK consumers really refinance their mortgages a lot more frequently in US. and much of Europe as well. So we're feeling the hit of higher interest rates more than elsewhere. All right. Thanks, James are going to look at some of those risks that we've been talking about now. We've got another poll. for you. We want to know what you think is the biggest risk for Global Economist, 2027. So the options are the AI bubble bursts and stock markets crash. Inflation is much higher than expected and stays higher for longer. a major new trade war, geopolitical conflicts, a sovereign debt or bond market crisis. a deep Chinese economic slowdown or new supply shocks. So lots of options. options there, lots of risks. Let's talk a little bit more in detail with James. It's not been a good few weeks for US stock market, James, and NASDAQ's down more than 10%. from its highs about a month ago. A lot of people are asking whether, you know, the... The AI bubble is finally starting to pop. It's early days. and our own base case is that the investment boom continues next year. But if that is wrong, and we do get a serious equity market correction, How does this change your outlook for the economy and the Fed? Yeah, no, I think it is clearly US Economist, quite vulnerable to this sort of... situation if it does indeed happen. For now it's not our base case because we do think that there is a strong pipe. for this coming through. And US policymakers see maintaining a lead in tech And AI, it's not only an economic consideration, International security issue as well. in their ongoing battle with China. So there's still a lot of willpower, a lot of desire to keep this story going. So for me, As I say, our base case remains, the pipeline remains strong in the growth story. remains very firm as well but if there is an asset asset value correction per se what could this mean well Well, as I mentioned earlier, our concern about US growth story is the lack of breadth. And when you look at what are the key growth drivers, it's those high-income households boosted by big... Wealth gains and it's that tech investment story. And if you do see tech valuations coming under pressure, say an equity market correction of 25, 30%. Plus that is going to who hits those high-income households pretty hard. in terms of their wealth. And that could be something. that leads them to become a little bit more cautious in their spending. But certainly I would imagine that if we do see a valuations correction, both equities and in terms of debt pricing as well. that is going to tighten financial conditions around the financing of the tech sector. And that is going to be right now. And I would imagine that that would... also pull back on the on the investment capex side as well so yes Valuations are very, very important because of that feedback through into the financial conditions tied to investment. but also the wealth effects story for the consumer as well. All right. Thanks, James. Don't forget to put your questions in the questions tab. We're going to get to them very shortly. but to Carsten now you touched on France earlier and the fact That's obviously politics is a major risk. 2027. but not one that has to derail the European growth story. Your bold call in the Eurozone, so this is a low probability. ...ability but high impact risk. is that we get another full-blown euro crisis. What would that look like? How would it happen? and what could the ECB do about it? Yeah, I think it's important to stress that this is not our base case because already I think a month ago we said that we do not expect. a second Eurozone debt crisis. coming out of France. I think that's important to stress, but just assume we were wrong. And how would this happen? I think currently the... the main contagion does not really come by a financial market. It becomes via societies and the and this intergenerational conflict that we're seeing between the young generation and the elderly generation. We see that here also the younger generation has shifted its focus. because on uh on economy So no longer on climate change. And then there's this cost of living crisis, housing affordability. ...ability issues are clearly a reason that that could trigger... more of debt crisis. So how would this mean? Not that the... The bond Markets just being contagious to the rest of Europe. but that other European countries will turn that back to to, well, solid public finances. trying to solve this intergenerational conflict by piling up more debt. and by either giving out more grants. more transfers, maybe also more investments. But take me really turning that back to this idea that That you need a stability-oriented public finances in Europe. If this was to happen, we were to see. more or less a collective increase in government debt ratios. Well, then we would have a new Eurozone debt crisis. Again, slightly different nature, but this would... clearly be a next step crisis. Notwithstanding the fact that we do have instruments like European stability mechanism. to more or less shield off contagion. we do have something like a single resolution mechanism. to also ring fans if needed. banks from creating more and more contagion and a widespread crisis. across Europe. So there are kind of instruments, but then you also asked about the ECB. And we think that if we really. were to end up... in a kind of new European sovereign debt crisis. then also the ECB would not refrain or would actually, no doubt. jump immediately into the bond Markets would also go for a whatever it takes. because in the end, the ECB remains the lender of last resort for... the monetary union if there was a the issue of an existential crisis. For the monetary union, we expect the ECB to intervene, to do whatever it takes to restart. Bond purchases, which then would also mean from Markets perspective in the run-up. to such an escalation we would see bond yields clearly going up further. But then the ECB would be a counter movement. coming in with whatever it takes with bond purchases. So also pushing back down. European bond yields. Okay, thank you, Carsten. I think I forgot to pull up the results of the poll about Bond purchases, I don't know if we have that, if we have those results. Somewhere. What is the probability the ECB has to restart bond purchases next year? 42% tend to... 25%. and 29%. say, a 50% chance. Okay, well, let's turn to the UK. okay now uh because there's also political risk here right in your uh outlook there's possibility for sort of possibility of snap election next year and what about the chances of the UK rejoining the EU? Yeah, like the UK has been quite boring recently, which is kind of good, but it's got everybody scratching their heads a bit. So we had a... budget a few weeks ago which was probably the most boring budget the UK's ever had yeah we've got Andy Burnham, who's got this bold vision. talking about 10-year plans for the UK. which is going to be setting out over the next few weeks. And people were kind of going, well, you know, there's only two or three years till the next election. you know is Andy Burnham kind of laying out his pitch for a vote next year. And a few signs hinting at this. There's a spending review that's been delayed till next year. This is where they allocate out all the government department. budgets fraught with political risk for the government so that would be naturally sort of thing you do after a vote. And also the EU, we're getting a lot of questions like, is the UK going to rejoin the EU? And I think the way we look at this is a lot of this is... might play into that electioneering. It's kind of helping Labour win back votes from other left-wing parties. Labour has gone from... 20 to 28 percent in the polls this year at a time where reform Nigel Farage's party has done the opposite. They've gone from 28% to 20%. So there might be a window of opportunity there. And you kind of, as you say, you mentioned the calls we make all these. sort of low risk, high probability, sort of risk cases. and one maybe is not only that we get an election. but actually that acts as a sort of referendum on EU membership and maybe that encourages the government to kind of plow ahead much more quickly than everybody expects. towards a closer relationship. Maybe something like a customs union, which involves less compromises on... on things like migration. So I think that's the big risk or surprise for next year. Okay, thanks James going to take a quick look at some of your questions now. I think maybe these are James Knightley. James, when Trump came in... In 2025, his agenda was to cut costs by a trillion. dollars while growing GDP. Cutting costs was not possible. and they decided to grow out of the debt problem. Now Democrats are likely to slow data center investments while federal spending and deficits have gone up Is US heading towards a debt crisis? Yeah, I mean if you look at the debt story it's not great. In the United States, we're borrowing 6.5% of GDP each year. That is not going to change because we're going to have gridlock. in Congress. So this fiscal position is not going to shift. over the next two years. So the dynamics continue at a time when we've got debt to GDP ratio in excess. of 100%. Now the idea that you can grow your way out of this debt story is where Bye. You've got a primary deficit, i.e. If you ignore the interest costs, the interest costs on US debt is about four percentage points of GDP. The primary deficit, i.e. tax revenues less departments or spending is a deficit of two and a half percent. So add them together, you get an overall fiscal deficit of six and a half. percent of GDP. Now just to keep the debt to GDP ratio stable what you need to do is get nominal GDP to be faster than your cost of borrowing. to the tune of your primary deficit. So essentially to keep the debt to GDP ratio stable At 100%, what we need to see is nominal growth in America. nominal GDP growth exceed the average cost of borrowing by two and a half percentage points. to offset that primary deficit. Now, that is going to be difficult. Because, of course, US borrowing costs have risen. You know, we're looking at a potential situation whereby US would need to see nominal growth. in excess of 7% to keep the debt to GDP ratio. stable. So certainly there are going to be challenges, but at the same time, you know. AI is seen as a potential. revolutionary story that can increase productivity dramatically, could revolutionize. government spending and programs there. So all is not lost, but the fiscal challenges are certainly... pretty significant and we do need to see This AI story really become a big theme that can boost growth and lower costs and make government more efficient. If that's the case, then yeah, I think we can. be okay on the debt story. But choice, we would be certainly in the camp that thinks that... So us getting back to US 10-year of say 425 is going to be a bit of stretch. We're much more inclined to look at the 10-year US Treasury yield as being an average around 5% or so. over the next year or two. Right. Thank James. This is an interesting question from Sid. there was a reference to the this one probably for Carsten so there was a reference to the K shape economy which talks about this uh in the u.s and the pass-through into consumer spending What is your take, Carsten, on similar dispersions in the eurozone through the lens of something like savings rates? across different demographics and the potential to influence inflation and or household spending under different fiscal and monetary regimes. Well, that is a question that probably requires an... own full webinar to answer it fully. We looked at this in the the past to see whether we can read whether we also detect these kind of k-shaped characteristics in the European economy and in some countries indeed you do see it. you also do clearly see differences in saving ratios. And not surprisingly, so we also have, we don't only have a kind of income driven, wealth driven, but also generationally. driven differences across European countries. what this now really means for monetary policy. for inflation in general. in my view. this current and so the K-shape or this kind of this dispersion across countries and demographics doesn't does not really have a a larger impact. What we're generally seeing is that the consumer even though for a long while we had always been hoping that the consumer might be become one of the growth drivers in Europe. If you currently look at this slight turning of the labor market. across Europe to the worst. If you also see that there is the pressure on industrial jobs. There is the fear of job losses due to AI. So this is currently a situation where we... Would not expect wage growth to really accelerate. This is so therefore. This is not a situation in which we expect private consumption to. your role in growth in 2027. in 2027 so you would really need first another turning of the labor Markets the for the better You would really need to see inflation coming down below 2%. percent very very fast And those elements are not part of our base case scenario. So which means for monetary policy and inflation. the consumer will rather be an offsetting factor for the increase in inflation that we're currently seeing. Hence, the consumer will be a reason why we expect the ECB not to hike in 2027. and could eventually be a reason also for the ECB. if consumption remains so subdued could be a reason for the ECB to actually consider maybe a rate cut. towards the end of next year. Okay, thanks, Kosta. Maybe one last question to James Knightley, again. In the last jobs report, we saw a small uptick in wages. How likely is it, in your opinion, that wages accelerate given immigration policy, labour shortages? i.e. labour shortages in some sectors. and recent strength in the jobs market, non-farm payrolls above the break-even rate. Yep, the latest payrolls report undoubtedly strong throughout. Unemployment fell, wages a little bit firmer. Payrolls growth coming in stronger, but In general, most of the labour indicators we have suggest that we are in this low hire, low firing. economy and for me the best lead indicator for wage growth is the quits rates it's the measure of Turnover in the jobs Markets not going to get wage growth unless you see turnover really pick up. i.e. companies are hiring and that's driving that recruitment process. And then other companies are fearful about losing staff. That's what means that So the retention pay starts picking up and you need those really to deliver that wage growth story. And I'm just not. Seeing that right now, I think we're in this low-hire, low-fare economy and the turnover in the jobs market remains very weak. That's not to say that there aren't hotspots and manufacturing is a really good story. Right now advanced manufacturing is really picking up. in the United States, partly Possibly the tariffs to some extent, but I think actually a key story. is of course the technology, the capex that's coming through. But additionally, remember that US has got actually pretty low energy costs relative to the rest of the world. Natural gas prices here, electricity prices here are substantially below. what the cost is in Europe and Asia. right now given their focus on Middle Eastern energy sourcing. So this has given US manufacturing story a really competitive, but competitiveness boost. So, yeah, I think manufacturing is the real standout where we are going to see more strength, where we are going to see more wage. Press is coming through. But outside of that, perhaps yet in farming and that sort of area where we are seeing immigration. controls bearing down in terms of labour supply that could be a factor but more broadly I want to see turnover. I want to see churn coming through to the jobs market. And we're just not seeing that yet. So for now. I'm pretty relaxed about the jobs as about the wage inflation narrative. Okay, we actually do have a couple more questions. So maybe we spend a bit more time. Just a few more minutes, because I think this is quite interesting and I don't know who could answer this. But what is the biggest disconnect today between what Markets is pricing? and what the ING Global Outlook implies. don't know who would want to Take a stab at that. I can start, Rebecca. I think it's on central banks. And where there's probably the... the largest difference for investors. We are probably a bit more dovish, even Markets pricing for both the Fed and the ECB, of course, has... going back and forth, but currently we are still more dovish. than market pricing also meaning if we are right this would clearly have an impact Markets and probably also then on on longer term interest rates. I think that is... Some. That is the most, most important difference. I don't know, Jameson Jameson. Any other thoughts? Maybe just to add to that, Carsten, I think one of the really interesting things is when you look at... that pricing that Carsten mentions. It's not just about the level of hikes. If you look in the UK, for example, we don't expect as many... rate hikes is the Markets actually more what happens thereafter Markets really pricing cuts at all, at least here in the UK, but I think it's similar in US and Europe. And that's where we differ. You know, we do expect rate cuts in all three of these economies by the end of next year. And at least in the case of US and the UK. okay into 2028 so probably it's not just about those the number of hikes but things Also about when he cuts the price too. Okay, brilliant. Sorry, one more question. If the ECB decides to revive bond purchase programs to tame the cost of... borrowing. Couldn't this deepen imbalances in European fiscal deficits? and expand sovereign debt burdens at the expense of artificial lower interest rates. In essence, Isn't it too early to see an easing of monetary policy, especially via less traditional tools such as QE? Well, that is why we call this bold. call also the the return of fiscal dominance in in Europe because you know as big The question actually suggests this is indeed what would happen. if the ECB had to restart asset purchases. Again, this is not our base case scenario and that is so in Global out. but you need to you need to be a bit a thinker to and to follow our our guidance so So not too simple. So the riskier call and the bold call are food for thought. are riskier calls but are not part of our base case scenario. And so part of our base case scenario is also not a return of the sovereign debt crisis. if everything, if we are really in the course of 27 in a world in which... almost all will be good. at least technically speaking. and in the case of Europe. We will continue seeing Global pressure. coming from China. So to do structural reforms. to do something to improve Europeans competitiveness. you will see that then indeed a central bank will also reconsider. easing of monetary policy. because this is what an ECB would be willing to do, namely... supporting growth, supporting indirectly, they would never admit it. And also supporting clearly. fiscal policies. All right. Thank you so much, Carsten Brzeski. James Knightley and James Smith. Lots more questions, actually. Quite a few questions about FX, but we have an entire webinar devoted to that. on Monday with Chris Turner and Francesco Pozzoli. So tune in for that. But that's all for now. If you do want to read our outlook, the full... publication is available on our website at think.ing.com. It's called ING Global... I look 2027 power play with that. I will say thank you very much and we'll see you next time.