Directional Economics: Central Europe’s new horizons, from investment hosts to global investors
Central Europe has achieved remarkable economic convergence, building on a legacy manufacturing base, skilled labour and foreign investment. For three decades, inward foreign direct investment (FDI) and exports have driven integration into global supply chains, bringing technology, know-how and rising incomes. As labour-cost advantages gradually fade, however, this growth model will become harder to sustain. The next phase of convergence will depend increasingly on the ability of domestic firms to expand internationally and build multinational businesses of their own.
In the third chapter of their study on the region’s growth model, Rafał Benecki and Michał Rubaszek will explain how outward direct investment (ODI) remains below levels typically associated with the current stage of economic development. They will also explore the benefits of ODI, present Polish corporates' views on the topic, and look at a policy agenda aimed at facilitating international expansion.
Additionally, we’ll be looking at the fiscal versus monetary policy trade-off across the region, getting an update on Hungary’s euro ambitions and discussing the latest trends in the CIS.
Details
Date: Thursday 29 October
Time: 1300 GMT/1400 CET
The webinar will last 45 minutes, including a Q&A session at the end.
The event will take place online and the waiting room will open 60 minutes ahead of the scheduled start time.
A joining link will be emailed following registration and you will receive a reminder email 10 minutes before the scheduled start time.
View transcript
Hello everyone and welcome to this semi-annual webinar that we put together to highlight all the key messages that we're delivering from our latest Directional Economics publication. Hopefully you received that into your inboxes last week. So once again we'll be taking a tour of Regional as well as doing a deep dive into some of the core subjects. which we think will be relevant for our customers here at ING. So I'm delighted to say that I'm joined today by here London with Francesc He's our expert in local currency rates and FX. in Regional and he's going to be covering the Czech Republic for us today. We're also joined in Warsaw by Rafa Frantisek and Mikhail Rubaszek. who will be deep diving into the main article in Directional and also Rafa. We'll be talking about Poland on the macro side today. We're also joined by Valentin Tataru in Bucharest, Peter Virovacz. in Budapest and Dimitri Dolgin as well. He's in Frankfurt and he covers... Caucasus and Central Asia for us. So let's start off with... I think we really want to go into the main article. To start with, over the years we focused on a number of different kind of topics. & just want to go first of all to you, Rafa. I mean, this particular article, we're talking about outward direct investment. & think it's the first time we've... Look to that. I mean, why did you choose that as a subject? Yes, good afternoon all. So let me. summarize Research achievements from the last few years so we started a series of of Research. ...analyzing the growth model of Central European economies and Poland. This is already the series containing three parts. We analyze the drivers of the growth model in the first This part which was called why beating the middle income trap is not enough. So the conclusion was that uh the success Regional economies was quite impressive but it relies so much on cheap They need more investments, more innovations. and in some cases also more credit. and scaling up. In the second part, we focused more on the labor market angle of the growth model. We also So analyzed how the labor market adjusted, that the employment rate grew. that the countries are importing labor, no longer exporting labor. but still we finalize with the same conclusion more leverage is needed. and the business need to rely more on productivity that and the growth model should be more innovative based. And now we turn to the third part of our series where we analyze one aspect of scaling the business, which is international expansion. So we look at the... external for direct investments which are produced by countries in Regional. We look at the cross-country comparisons. compared to the level of development of other develop economies, emerging economies and look at this specific metric which is all the ODE. so outward direct investments And the conclusion from this part of Research will be presented by Michal. Brilliant. Thanks very much, Rafa. Yeah, let's go to Mikael now. So, Michal, I think in your work, you would say that... Perhaps Regional is punching below its weight in terms of... perhaps where you would expect foreign investment to be right now. Yes, yes, definitely. My opinion is that Regional punch below its weight in terms of output direct investment. And my argument is based on... framework, a well-recognized framework that is linking the level of economic development. to international investment position. It's called investment development. So it classified five stages of investment development. and let me give Paul a example so in the 90s we were in stage one we were low in ...come country, almost no FDI. no ODI. Yay. so the stocks were very low and in mid 90s investors It's recognized that Poland is an attractive place to invest. So you can see that the stock of foreign direct investment increased. increase to about 40% of GDP. still the level of ODI remained very low. and since 2010 so previous slide please so since 2010 We stayed with foreign direct investment. at about 40% of GDP, but the level of ODI is very low our gdp increased and now we are high middle income country or even high income country. So according to this investment development path, we should be in stage four. deeply in stage four, but we are still in stage three. And next. slides so we also provide the cross-country comparison so we've got a fitted line so potential of ODI and you can see that Poland, Romania, Turkey with GDP per capita at about 40,000. US dollar should be somewhere close to 20% off. of the eye, 20% of GDP. Pete? and it's closer to five percent. The Hungarian picture is distorted by special purpose. as entities so if we subtract this financial intermediation since about seven percent so So still lagging behind and Czechia is the only. The country from Regional that is. with 25% of GDP close to the fitted line. What we expect is that with convergence... both in GDP per capita and also with our companies going. multinational the level of ODI should be. closer to 20-30% of GDP. be done currently so we punch below our weight and there are reasons for that. Great. Well, what's a big deal about ODI anyway? Why should a country... you know, care about it. Yeah. Chris, it's a good question. So we are growing. So our GDP per capita is increasing. And we might say that our growth model is okay because it's functioning. but what functioned in the past. does not mean that must work in the future. And at a certain stage of development, we wrote about This last year is that we've got labor scarcity so our growth should switch from labor intensive into investment intensive or innovation intensive. And if you think about the productive companies that are domestically based are not investing abroad so if they invest abroad they can scale up If they scale up, they've got more customers. higher Turner Better recognize brand names. So these companies can allow to invest more in automatization. in R&D and to change the structure of growth from labor intensive into innovation intensive. and in the article we also provide channels macroeconomic channel so it's firm level but on macroeconomic scale there are a number of channels. & think we've got it on the presentation. the diagram based on a survey of over 100 academic studies. So it's not only about companies that have higher profits. Also, this company is investing abroad, so it's importing. Know-how from abroad, so it's transfer of knowledge. The companies are investing more in R&D. See? But also you see industrial upgrading, so you are moving. Upward in value-added ladder. & part of that... domestic company that operates abroad also import subcomponents from services and goods from home Economist, exports is increasing. So there's vast evidence that outward direct investment is good for growth. So most studies are supporting this. thesis and that's why we think that Outward direct investment is the next engine of growth. for Regional. Okay, interesting. And what about the role of governments here? I mean, you write in the report. what governments can actually do to support that. But also there's a limit, right, in terms of how far they should go. then the private sector should take it further. What are your thoughts on that? Yeah, so we are quite explicit on that in the report. And our framework is that a company decides to invest abroad. It's productive enough. so a company that is functioning quite well and see opportunity Opportunities to invest abroad will invest abroad, but... The factor constraining for an expansion is the fixed cost of entering foreign markets. And if these costs are high, so only very large... companies decide to invest abroad. And the role of government is to create institutions that are responsible for internationalization. that are helping companies to invest abroad. So, these kinds of institutions are already there in our countries and we describe them. in detail. So it's pipe in Poland, Czech trade. like pepa in Hungary or rice in Romania. but if we look what these institutions are doing, they are... predominantly focusing on attracting foreign direct investment and promoting exports with very little focus on Helping domestic companies to go multinational. And the policies that are quite successful. in international standards. are to lower fixed costs of entering foreign Markets it's foreign diplomacy. It's legal assistance, market intelligence, partner seeking. also financing schemes. insurance instruments and there are examples so so we just refer to two good examples from Asian Tigers, Enterprise Singapore and Kotra from South Korea. which are doing something that is... Really? in line what we are claiming lowering fixed cost of foreign market However, as you mentioned, please. We also say that it shouldn't be the role of the government to pick up domestic companies that should go abroad. So it's not about selecting. companies but just rather horizontal type of policies of supporting companies to enter foreign Markets lowering this fixed cost. of investment. Okay, that's great. Many thanks, Michal. And this is all, you know. Some of it's kind of theoretical, but I think... We've got some interesting, perhaps some practical insights from on the ground in Poland. So if we go back. I know you've done kind of corporate surveys and And yeah, tell us about what the local kind of corporations are telling you about the subject. Yeah, so the key bottom line from Research is whether the companies are prepared for this international expansion. And our conclusion is the following. Yes, they are prepared. And there are a few important metrics which led us to determine this readiness. First is, of course, Starting from this. top-down measures First, if we look at the level of development of the economies. they they reach the level of development which deserves more ODA. So that's the first point. The second point. If you look at the productivity of the top companies comparing to the EU average, They are productive, enough productive. to start ODI expansion. Another important conclusion is that if we look at the geographical destination of the ODI So central European economies are mainly focused on... in their expansion on European markets. which is quite natural. The entry costs are more limited there. But the next step should be... to enter other destinations Markets outside EU. and that requires more support from the authorities. The last thing is, are these opinions of the companies alone and we have sea level interviews. which help us to determine what companies are thinking about yourself when it comes to the potential to expansion. And the conclusion is, once again, they are ready to expand. They think that international expansion is to providing additional capacity for funding. R&D for funding technology and innovations. they can build larger scale. And also... By doing that, they can dilute the cost also. So the bottom line is there is space for improvement. more ODI is the natural path for growth model to expand and sustain. the transition of the economies which were quite successful in the last three decades. Sure, indeed, Rafa. yeah let's We're going to now to... Think about a poll actually. So we're finishing that section. So thanks for the... Yeah, Rafa, for the kind of the local insights there. We're now going to move to a different section. We're looking at more the macro side and the monetary side. And let's start off with a poll. We know Bonn yields this summer. have exploded to the upside. They've really exposed weaknesses in France. budget problems unresolved there. But let's ask you guys in the audience, in terms of which countries... the local sovereign bond Markets these four countries. which of those do you think will be most susceptible to the sort of external shock, most exposed to the rise in... higher bond yields overseas. So let's see what people are saying. We'll let that kind of run for second. Yeah, when we go back to those poll results, actually, so... So, um... Let's go to Rafa again. We're going to talk about the kind of the macro side. Rafa, so... and bond Markets general and fiscal spending. You've got elections in November in Poland. What about the government? Has it got room to spend? Are there room for price caps on energy? What's the view? Yeah, so the simple answer is there is no space for further expansion. in general. But when it comes to the specific question on the fuel cap. I think the government has funding from the windfall tax. And... I can imagine that the fuel cap may last Our assumption is till February. while the windfall tax can be more long-lasting. and should provide funding Our understanding is that the fuel cap will last until February because In March, there is a nice base effect in inflation. and should nicely offset the... suspension of the fuel cap. So, So, so, so... And with that, we'll have inflation path. close to the upper bound in the coming next year. Otherwise, if the fuel cap will be suspended earlier, for example at the end of December then we can face jump of inflation above four percent which is very unpopular. So the bottom line there is space for Fuel Cup. when it comes to other broader sense of fiscal space. I think there is no fiscal space. There are a few important constraints. One is the local debt threshold at the level of 55% of GDP. This is based on the local definition. country will be flirting with the debt at this level in next year. That's why the finance minister provided when he provided new lower taxes, personal income taxes, they were offset by higher corporate income taxes. So this is new. in the managing fiscal side, definitely not enough. This is not... not to learn form this is not expected fiscal consolidation. but that presents a kind of changing attitude. More to come after elections. Okay, thanks. And how about a very quick word now? What about the ratings outlook, the recent ratings outlook? From Moody's. What's next on the rating story for Poland? Yeah, Moody's seems to be satisfied with the decision they've taken, so... So they cut the rating but put outlook on neutral. They're probably the most tricky. The rating agency is S&P. They have still neutral rating, so we need to switch to negative outlook. sorry outlook it looks like the rating agencies are need to adjust to the new fiscal path which is 7.1% of GDP deficit in 2025. and over 7% in 26 and 27. So we are on the edge of the downgrade. depends when it happens but Markets pricing at least two notches cuts of the rating Okay, thanks. And just finally, how does the central bank react? to all this like a pro inflationary kind of fiscal policy Are they going to hike? Our baseline forecast is that the central bank Can wait and will provide hikes but less than priced. by Markets, by the yield curve. So we see hike in... the first quarter by 50 basis point. The short rationale is that there are no second round effects. Poland is looking a bit better than Czechia for example with that respect. But still, the longer energy crisis is lasting, the more likely that some kind of second round effect may appear. So that's why we see limited hikes at the beginning of 27. But still... Fiscal side is not an important ingredient. fiscal side is not inflationary now, the high deficit is to some extent explained by the defense which is It's import intensive. It's not adding that much. as a new delta to domestic demand. If we look at the minimum wages. Public sector wages, they grow at 3%. percent so in real terms The real wages are decreasing and that is very important anchor which is preventing second round effects to materialize. So from that point of view, things are looking under control. The main point is how long headline will be. above 3.5. That's why we decided for hikes in the first quarter. Okay, that's brilliant. Thanks very much, Rafa. Let's turn to Romania now and Valentin. So perhaps it's gone under the radar a little bit, Valentin, but there's actually... You've been some successful fiscal consolidation in Romania this year. What's the outlook for the next couple of years now when you've got a general election in 2028 as well? and obviously and recently unstable political environment seems. perhaps a little settled more what do you think Yeah, well, let me start first with... with what we know. So first, we know that fiscal consolidation is clearly. delivering as you mentioned uh so the deficit at the end of september was three 0.8 percent significantly better than a year ago about one & half percentage points better And second, we know that we have a government that should last for at least six months this being the minimum period during which the liberals and the and Prime Minister Niculescu agreed not to back our proposal. any no confidence motion. Now, I get it that six months may not sound like political stability by most European standards but by recent Romania standards, I would take it. It is certainly enough to prepare the 2027 budget. and to somehow lock in the next step of fiscal consolidation. And of course, it doesn't mean that the government will automatically fall after six months. but more importantly The broad fiscal direction is already anchored in Romania. by the excessive deficit procedure And in practice, I didn't. see any major political force challenging that direction. So, 2027, I think we should see consolidation continuing. probably taking the deficits. towards the low 5% area. Of course, 2028 is obviously more difficult to call given the elections. But I would say that recent experience suggests that spending a lot of money before elections is no longer a problem. particularly reliable way. of getting people to vote you. So perhaps fiscal discipline and political survival. are no longer completely opposing. concepts. All right, thanks, Valentin. Now, if we look at the poll results in terms of which... Which bond Markets most susceptible to the rise in external yields? Seems like Romania is in... the front line here. I mean, do you think the rating downgrade risk, is that still going to be with us? Or we're out of the woods, as you might say. No, we are certainly not out of the woods, but I do think that we may have. The past the point of maximum danger. So the important change is that fiscal consolidation is now producing results. It's not just promises. And that clearly helps. It's the main anchor. Of course, one or two years actually of budget execution, good budget execution is not. enough to remove the rating risk. in the end the deficit and the financing needs. remain large. So I would say that the next test. will come quite quickly for for the new government budget revision for for 2026 which we should see in a couple of weeks and in my view this will to clarify that 2026 will not be a year of significant overachievement on the fiscal side, as some may hope. And then more importantly, a credible 2027 budget rate. Agents need to see that what happened last year and this year. is part of multi-year adjustment rather than one of... So I would say that the immediate downgrade risk has probably faded. Definitely it hasn't disappeared and this 2027 budget will be. See? very important in determining how much further Romania can move away from this risk. We will see the budget draft. probably in about a month. That's fairly soon. and the actual vote sometime in early December, I guess. Okay, thanks. Let's wrap it up with central bank policies. So we've seen the disinflation... trend perhaps stall a bit central bank's got to deal with still high inflation Fiscal consolidation, where does the central bank go from here? I think the NBR balances this risk that that you've mentioned pretty much by what is doing now which is not rushing into action in either direction. Yeah, weak growth would argue for lower rates, but then in inflation and the fiscal situation argue for caution. So keeping the policy rate unchanged for over two years now. can look like in action but A decision has actually been made at every policy meeting and so far The NVR has judged that. staying put offers the best balance of risks. Looking into next year, I don't expect. expect any change in this approach so purely from a domestic perspective the conditions for rate cuts should improve. even significantly as inflation comes down towards the the four four & half area by the end of next year So at some point, the domestic data will give. the NBR permission to cut. The question is whether the rest of the world will give this permission. and for the moment at least external environment seems to argue Thank you, brother, for caution. more caution rather than less. Okay, that's great. Many thanks, Valentin. So we're going to now turn to the Czech Republic here London with Frantisek. And just going back to the subject of bonds. So now you can look at particularly local bonds kind of closely in the bond Markets general. So S&P Rating Agency recently improved the outlook. But at the same time, I think you notice that. you tell us that the government is actually proposing quite a sort of wide kind of budget deficit. So how do you... Square the circle there. Yeah, I think we need to know the political context for this. Czech Republic had a general election in in 2025 at the end of the year so we have new government basically this is the first budget fully under control of the new governments obviously includes a lot of election promises also from some higher investments and the higher defense spending. but I would say it's still one of first the junior coalition partners. doesn't like higher deficits so there is some question the government obviously also the opposition is criticizing the horror. deficit and we've seen it didn't go really well with the population which is still like in the past were fiscally conservative. So I would say that... Check fiscal responsivity doesn't go away. And this is really the one-off. We're probably going to see some consolidation in the future years, which is also... painted in the government plan, which I would say is not overly optimistic. So I would say we can really expect... I think that this government is going to deliver a lower deficit in the in the coming years and there is not that much changing in the Czech fiscal mind. Okay, thanks. And what about, you know, what is the government like in terms of... I suppose, populist measures or cost of living measures in terms of... bringing in price caps, energy caps, and what is that? Yeah, I think... Maybe, contrary to what I said about the fiscal, this government can be more active. They're definitely going to be more active than the previous government. We've seen obviously a big spike in the inflation in 2020. This government actually was criticizing the previous government for little or no action against the inflation. So I would expect them to. be more active but still i would say very cautiously about the fiscal. and not to spend too much money because as we can see also from the previous elections that this This also doesn't go well with the population, so it's very difficult to to make Czech people happy. but uh on one way on one hand you you don't have to or you You cannot spend too much. On the other, you have to do something. So they're going to be more active, but not. not too much and still probably lagging against the or behind the sea countries. Interesting. And what does that all mean for the central bank? Because it's one of the most hawkish in Regional. I know money Markets pricing quite a lot of kind of tightening. Where do you think that story runs from here? Yeah, well, CMB is basically the most aggressive for hockey center bank in Regional. the only one who hiked the race since the beginning of the US-Iran conflict. We think there is more to it. We have a meeting next week actually. We think the CMB is going to hike again. So now the question is more how much more they can deliver. New forecast which I think is going to be very important for the indication. As a baseline we have so far just Just one more hike next week, but I think we are ready to add more into the... into the forecast based on the CME communication next week. I would say February meeting definitely is going to be live after the January inflation. which are important for the for the central bank Still, it's not really enough as Markets is pricing 100 basis points or further. tightening. But I think I have some understanding why Markets is pricing this because the CMB proved in the past they can be very aggressive in rate hikes. Obviously, the inflation is going to go up. So I think. it's kind of reasonable to expect the same. We can surprise on the... the hockey side great thanks very much friendship so yeah we're now going to move to Hungary actually We're going to do a deep dive into Hungary euro ambitions with Peter Virovacz. in Budapest. But before we go to him, we're going to have a quick poll about, yeah. Hungary Euro ambition. So. Which year, in which year, will Hungary adopt the Euro? So 2031. 32, 34. never. Let's, we'll let that Poland of cook. for bit, but let's go over to... Peter. So... So I think it's quite a big medium term fiscal plan that was announced recently, I think last. week a lot of focus on that in the context of its euro ambitions And you were London. It's great to see you kind of last week, seeing a lot of kind of customers and getting kind of local feedback. So, yeah, what was your kind of... first impressions on that budget. Yeah, indeed. It was a really intense week, definitely. with all the all the announcements regarding the 2027 budget and also regarding the midterm fiscal plan, the fiscal consideration plan. because Hungary is still under excessive deficit procedure. But in the meantime, the government is having a clear political willingness. to join the Eurozone probably as quickly as possible. But now I guess... they are trying to front load. all the fiscal consolidation, we start from 7.5%. percent of GDP deficit and they are trying to cut it back. below 5% in 2027. Now, first of all, the macro backdrop. I believe the plan and the macro plan looks more or less realistic. And that was the main question from our clients. during London Roadshow. And obviously, nowadays, it's really hard to guess what is going to happen in the next 24. hours even so it's really hard to say whether it is realistic or not, but as things are. or seeing or looking now I think It was a realistic & fair plan. & believe this kind of front loading can work, especially focused on... and on the expenditure cutting side. levy spending, unnecessary spending, so this kind of stuff. combined with some tax measures. And in general, I guess... So some of the tax cuts because there will be some. In the meantime, we will support consumption growth and GDP growth. be in the vicinity of two to three percent and it is aligned with ING house you So altogether, I think there are no big issues with the budget. Though I would mention two, which are kind of interesting. So the budget and the midterm budget plan are just a 27 budget, but the midterm plan. and was based on an OIA price of $80. which is looking kind of low now. definitely so this is a clear risk but the budget is having some built-in reserves to cover that issue. It is like 0.5% of GDP this year, 0.3% of GDP. be next year just to make sure if energy prices are are moving even higher or remaining at recent highs. then still the budget will be more or less okay. And yeah, on the labor Markets government is expecting some. kind of labour market expansion which for me looks to be a bit optimistic. because the path they are talking about would put Hungary in the... top three of all EU member states regarding the the labor market ratios like that. employment rate. So that could be the most interesting gap. a part of it but in general i think paths look realistic & believe the fiscal consideration is definitely doable. Okay, thanks. And what about on the inflation side, right? Because obviously inflation... It's exploding around the world, but it doesn't seem to be the case in Hungary there. Is it just for matter of time before we run into trouble? There's a different story there. Yeah, I don't think it is a train wreck in slow motion. So, so far, so good. Definitely. And of course, there will be some kind of acceleration going forward. But Hungary... is on an island, definitely. We have sub 2% year-on-year inflation rate on average this year. it will remain below 2%. percent Next year, probably around 3% only. With the latest inflation target change, 2.5% is the new target. target from January the 1st, 2028. So the National Bank of Hungary will take care of it, that's for sure. But in general, there are a lot of measures still in place. like for household energy, the utility cost reduction scheme is still on it probably it will be changed in the in the next four years but now it is still on. and helping a lot on the fuel price side. Hungary is having the lowest increase in fuel prices. And this is because how the CPI basket, the consumer price basket. that is made in Hungary, petrol prices are more important for households than diesel. prices. And that's why... uh these are price of gasoline prices are skyrocketing petrol prices are behaving more or less and this is the reason why we haven't seen this kind of component. just pushing the general inflation higher. And also we can say that the margin freezes from the previous government. is still on the food, for example. It is going to be phased out pretty soon, probably by the end of the year, but you're not expecting. a really major impact, of course, repricing will start. You're going to see about 3% inflation mid next year and like 3.5% maybe. but still as of now the strengthening of the Hungarian foreign was really helping. on the imported inflation part. So in general, we can say that the inflation story is looking kind of favorable. But unfortunately, obviously, all Global risk sentiment is... is definitely not happening. Hungary is still a small open economy. So we are struggling to cope with all of this kind of... issues and this is giving some hard time I guess for the monetary policy as well. Yeah, no, thanks, Peter. And then just finally, if we have a quick look at the poll results. So let's see what... The Yeah. Our customers think of... the most likely time 2032 what do you think about that peter just um quickly if that's okay Yes, so 2032. Indeed, it seems that the government is selling the Eurodoption narrative. in a credible way, joined by the National Bank of Hungary as well. So altogether, we believe that 2032 is doable. of course um um have a lifting and needs to be done in the fiscal policy but the inflation we were also interesting I guess that's why the government is trying to focus on pro-inflationary fiscal measures early on. like in in 27 and and get this out of the way and we'll be able to meet with David Namastu targets by 2030. Also, there is an ambition to join the ERM2 as soon as 2029. and that makes possible the 2030 Euro adoption. So all together. I guess for instability, FX stability is key. That's why we believe the National Bank of Hungary. is keeping a close eye on Global developments, the risk sentiment. and also definitely on the central banks in Regional. We believe if things are not improving generally. in the risk sentiment and BH will remain on hold but but we see foreign range trading That means between 350 and 370. probably closer to the upper bound now. but if there will be some improvement in the risk sentiment going forward in energy prices. we can see lowering euro half levels maybe as low as 3.55 if there will be a significant improvement in the risk sentiment and that will open the door. In front of easing, of course, is a big if. That's great. Thank you so much, Peter. Really great insights locally there in Hungary. And just finally, yeah. Let's turn to beyond Central Europe to the Caucasus and Central Asia and let's hear from Dimitri Dolgin in terms of So if we broaden the discussion beyond Central Europe, which we've been discussing so FI mean... How do you think Regional as a whole is some positions really in terms of to the current global environment. Yes, so the broad picture is that the CCA region has held up quite well. And yes, Global environment has been challenging for Markets this year, but The CCA seems to be broadly fine. But there are quite big differences across countries and also in what actually is driving that resilience. There's also one thing I could add to the CEE investment story that we discussed. because earlier um i mean on the on the corporate side and on the private side cca economies are still mostly on the receiving end Global investment flows so they're not quite the outward investors yet. At the same time, the Regional large sovereign wealth funds, they remain important. and investors in Global Markets moving to the Regional stories. Beyond the investment flows, if we look at Armenia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, these are the four. countries that we cover in Regional so far. There are quite some, I would say, fairly strong domestic buffers. to note but they're very different from country to country. So very briefly, Armenia has strong remittance inflows and comfortable reserves. Azerbaijan has very large sovereign assets with high oil prices providing some additional financial support. In Kazakhstan, high real rates are an important buffer together with the back. of state FX sales, providing a cushion for the Tenge when there is a need. for that. And Uzbekistan has very strong economic growth, solid gold. ...proceeds and probably the most clearly positive sovereign rating story in the four. of the four. And ratings are worth mentioning because the general direction unlike some cases, for the entire region has been positive. Credit fundamentals have improved and access to international Markets been getting better. But of course, there are vulnerabilities as well. like in all the cases. For example, Armenia is quite dependent on external flows. Azerbaijan is still highly dependent on hydrocarbons. Kazakhstan has become more exposed to portfolio flows and Uzbekistan. continues to face high risk of overheating and re-acceleration of inflation. And that brings us back to rates. As you can see on the chart, hopefully real rates. are quite high especially in Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan. And that gives both central banks some room to cut even against the current external backdrop which some see as hawkish and it is in some cases. But Global rates stay high and inflation pressures... persist, so talking about higher for longer scenario, that room can disappear. Quite quickly, capital inflows could weaken, currencies could come under pressure. and that would feed back into inflation. So overall, to sum up, I'll describe our original view as cautiously constructive. There are meaningful buffers, but Global environment still matters a lot, especially through capital flows, currencies and inflation. Brilliant. Thanks so much, Dimitri. Yeah, and we've got two minutes over. I'm sure that... The press conference is just starting as we speak. So I'd like to thank all of our speakers today for great insights from the regions. And please take a look at that publication, a lot more detail on all the economies and particularly that. outward direct investment article um we'll be producing one again probably march april next year And yeah, you know where we are. So please reach out. to us and thanks for dialing in today take care